CBC News Posted: Feb 10, 2014 4:45 PM PT| Last Updated: Feb 11, 2014 11:24 AM PT
More than a half dozen seniors homes in B.C. do not have potentially life-saving fire sprinkler systems, raising serious concerns about the safety of the province’s residential care facilities.
CBC News has learned that eight of 359 public and private care homes in B.C. have no sprinklers: Craigdarroch Care Home in Victoria, Douglas Care Community in Victoria, Halliday House in Parksville, Joan Crescent Manor in Victoria, Lady Minto Extended Care on Salt Spring Island, South Granville Park Lodge in Vancouver, Stuart Lake Hospital in Stuart Lake, and Wrinch Memorial Hospital in Hazelton.
Terry Horton’s dad lives in a care home with no sprinklers
Terry Horton says he was surprised to learn the South Granville Park Lodge, where his 89-year-old father lives, does not have a fire sprinkler system. (CBC)
Terry Horton’s 89-year-old father lives at South Granville Park Lodge, a four-storey structure that is home to more than 100 seniors. He said it was a “complete surprise” that the care home does not have sprinklers.
“I thought this was a first class facility and I expected in every way it would be up to code and have all the necessary safety equipment,” said Horton.
“My father’s on the fourth floor. He’s recently broken a hip so he has to use a walker. I know a lot of the residents are in wheel chairs. I would expect if there was a fire, it would be pretty difficult to get all the residents out in a timely manner. So sprinklers, in that case, would be very important.”
Older buildings do not require sprinklers
South Granville Park Lodge was built 45 years ago, before the B.C. Building Code was changed to make sprinklers mandatory in all care facilities and residential buildings four-storeys or higher. However, the 1992 amendment does not require older buildings to be retrofitted with sprinklers unless there are other major renovations being done.
As a result, the care home has been labelled “high risk” by the Vancouver Fire Department.
“The sprinklers provide the time it takes for us to get into the building, and it holds the fire in the area of origin. It is a huge concern when they are not,” said deputy fire chief Steven Laleune.
The owner of South Granville Park Lodge told CBC News installing sprinklers, which would involve moving frail residents around, could be costly and logistically difficult. He says he is, however, getting a feasibility study done on what a sprinkler retrofit would require.
Horton said he expects residents and their families would be willing to bear some of the expense.
“I’d like it to be brought up to code. If that means paying a bit more to do that, I’d be willing to do that,” said Horton.
Building code changes could be coming
On Jan. 23, a fire at a seniors home in L’Isle-Verte, Quebec, claimed the lives of at least 28 people, with as many as four residents still considered missing. The home did not have a fire sprinkler system.
■L’Isle-Verte seniors’ home fire started in resident’s room: source
■L’Isle-Verte seniors’ home fire raises ire over sprinkler regulation
Last April, one elderly resident was killed and 12 were sent to hospital after a fire ripped through a four-storey seniors complex in Langley, B.C. The 30-year-old building also did not have a sprinkler system.
Both fires raised questions about whether enough is being done in Canada to keep elderly care home residents safe.
■B.C. seniors group calls for sprinkler upgrades after fatal fire
■Fatal fires involving seniors’ homes in Canada
■B.C. seniors’ homes reviewing safety following Quebec fire
The B.C. Ministry of Health said, in addition to the eight care homes without sprinkler systems, there are nine that are only “partially sprinklered”: Berwick House in Victoria, Brock Fahrni Pavilion in Vancouver, Cooper Place in Vancouver, Fraserview Intermediate Care Lodge in Richmond, Greenwoods Eldercare Society on Salt Spring Island, New Vista Society in Burnaby, Pinegrove Place Care Home in Richmond, Rosewood Manor in Richmond, and Sutherland Hills Rest Home in Kelowna.
The Ministry said all the facilities are in compliance with the Community Care and Assisted Living Act, as well as the building codes that were in place when they were constructed.
Meanwhile, the B.C. government said it will be meeting with care home operators in the next few weeks to discuss sprinkler retrofits
Mia’s thoughts- I am tired of hearing hospital and elder care centers crying”it’s an old building were exempt” or we didn’t know or any other excuse, If you want to profit from the care of our loved ones don’t open in a building that cannot protect them in all situations, when I opened restaurants we looked at hundreds of properties until we found one with the ability to meet all requirements legal and aesthetic half way doesn’t count our loved ones are not collateral damage to guarantee your bottom line get it right or shut your doors.